X
Follow Reality Bite on Facebook
15:39
TV
TV

Doctor Who review: 'Demons of Punjab shows how taking risks can pay off'

Monday 12th November 2018
Image

The episode of Doctor Who that went out on Remembrance Sunday featured meadows of poppies in Punjab and battlefield flashbacks to Singapore, as the series did its bit to ensure that the tremendous losses of colonial troops weren’t forgotten.

If ever a Doctor Who episode seemed doomed to go badly wrong it was Demons of Punjab. That it not only worked but was genuinely moving is a credit to the script by playwright Vinay Patel—astonishingly only the second person of colour ever to write for Doctor Who.

It all began with that time travel staple, the stopped clock—in this case a watch given to Yaz (Mandip Gil) by her grandmother Umbreen. Yaz had the Doctor (Jodie Whittaker) trace it back in time—and stumbled upon Umbreen’s (Amita Suman) secret first marriage in rural Punjab.

As well as not being Yaz’s future granddad, Umbreen’s groom Prem (Shane Zaza) was a Hindu. By marrying a Muslim just as the departing British Empire carved India up into separate states for Hindus and Muslims, Prem set himself against his bigoted brother Manish (Hamza Jeetooa) who had taken Partition to heart.

With the benefit of 21st century hindsight, the clash between the brothers’ world views was settled in advance, with a cataclysm of ethnic cleansing that killed a million people and displaced ten million more. We learned early on that Prem wouldn’t survive, and the episode worked as a chronicle of death foretold.

Next Doctor Who odds

Aliens with tusks, multiple eyes and a preposterous name only underscored the theme: this episode was about mourning, not explaining. Prem repeatedly asked, “What happened to you, little brother?” and got no answer. But he rightly didn’t flinch at pointing the finger upwards to blame India’s British governor Lord Mountbatten. 

Though less overtly political than Rosa last month, Demons of Punjab raised equally probing questions about modern Britain and the imperial history it still hasn’t come to terms with.

It was fantastic to find out more about Yaz, a character who’s too often been sidelined, and to give Gil some acting to do. The episode certainly wouldn’t have worked without her, and there were a few cringe moments when well-intentioned lines from white characters didn’t quite take their context into account.

But all in all, where last week’s The Tsuranga Conundrum showed the dangers of playing it too safe, Demons of Punjab showed how taking risks can pay off.

Next Doctor Who odds

Michaela Coel 7/1
Kris Marshall 7/1
Maxine Peake 8/1
Natalie Dormer 8/1
Tom Rosenthal 10/1
David Harewood 11/1
Vicky Mcclure 12/1
Phoebe Waller-Bridge 14/1
James Norton 14/1
Tilda Swinton 16/1
Richard Rankin 16/1
Jenna Coleman 20/1
Olivia Colman 20/1
Andrew Buchan 25/1
Paterson Joseph 25/1
Ben Whishaw 33/1
James Purefoy 33/1
Maisie Williams 33/1
Robert Carlyle 33/1
Richard Ayoade 33/1
Tom Ellis 33/1
Joanne Froggatt 33/1
Richard Madden 33/1
Zawe Ashton 33/1
Lara Pulver 33/1
Suranne Jones 33/1
Amanda Mealing 33/1
Sheridan Smith 33/1
Katie Mcgrath 33/1
Rory Kinnear 40/1
Alice Eve 40/1
Catherine Tate 40/1
Daniel Kaluuya 40/1
Andy Serkis 40/1
Charlotte Rampling 40/1
Russell Tovey 40/1
Andrew Scott 40/1
Michelle Dockery 40/1
Helen Mirren 40/1
Sacha Dhawan 40/1
Alexandra Roach 40/1
Eddie Izzard 50/1
Gillian Anderson 50/1
Frank Milham 50/1
Helena Bonham Carter 50/1
Ben Daniels 50/1
Alfred Enoch 50/1
Idris Elba 50/1
James Darcy 50/1
Gemma Arterton 50/1
Sanjeev Bhaskar 50/1
Russell Brand 50/1
David Walliams 50/1
Adrian Lester 50/1
Carey Mulligan 50/1
James Corden 80/1
Stephen Fry 80/1
Benedict Cumberbatch 80/1
Domhnall Gleeson 80/1
Alan Davies 80/1
Alan Carr 100/1
Katie Hopkins 110/1
Katie Price 110/1

Next Doctor Who odds

BEST ODDS
1. Michaela Coel
7/1
FREE BET ODDS
2. Kris Marshall
7/1
FREE BET ODDS
3. Maxine Peake
8/1
FREE BET ODDS
4. Natalie Dormer
8/1
FREE BET ODDS
5. Tom Rosenthal
10/1
FREE BET ODDS
6. David Harewood
11/1
FREE BET ODDS
7. Vicky Mcclure
12/1
FREE BET ODDS
8. Phoebe Waller-Bridge
14/1
FREE BET ODDS
9. James Norton
14/1
FREE BET ODDS
10. Tilda Swinton
16/1
FREE BET ODDS
11. Richard Rankin
16/1
FREE BET ODDS
12. Jenna Coleman
20/1
FREE BET ODDS
13. Olivia Colman
20/1
FREE BET ODDS
14. Andrew Buchan
25/1
FREE BET ODDS
15. Paterson Joseph
25/1
FREE BET ODDS
16. Ben Whishaw
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
17. James Purefoy
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
18. Maisie Williams
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
19. Robert Carlyle
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
20. Richard Ayoade
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
21. Tom Ellis
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
22. Joanne Froggatt
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
23. Richard Madden
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
24. Zawe Ashton
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
25. Lara Pulver
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
26. Suranne Jones
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
27. Amanda Mealing
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
28. Sheridan Smith
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
29. Katie Mcgrath
33/1
FREE BET ODDS
30. Rory Kinnear
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
31. Alice Eve
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
32. Catherine Tate
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
33. Daniel Kaluuya
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
34. Andy Serkis
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
35. Charlotte Rampling
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
36. Russell Tovey
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
37. Andrew Scott
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
38. Michelle Dockery
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
39. Helen Mirren
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
40. Sacha Dhawan
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
41. Alexandra Roach
40/1
FREE BET ODDS
42. Eddie Izzard
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
43. Gillian Anderson
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
44. Frank Milham
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
45. Helena Bonham Carter
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
46. Ben Daniels
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
47. Alfred Enoch
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
48. Idris Elba
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
49. James Darcy
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
50. Gemma Arterton
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
51. Sanjeev Bhaskar
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
52. Russell Brand
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
53. David Walliams
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
54. Adrian Lester
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
55. Carey Mulligan
50/1
FREE BET ODDS
56. James Corden
80/1
FREE BET ODDS
57. Stephen Fry
80/1
FREE BET ODDS
58. Benedict Cumberbatch
80/1
FREE BET ODDS
59. Domhnall Gleeson
80/1
FREE BET ODDS
60. Alan Davies
80/1
FREE BET ODDS
61. Alan Carr
100/1
FREE BET ODDS
62. Katie Hopkins
110/1
FREE BET ODDS
63. Katie Price
110/1
FREE BET ODDS
Odds correct as of 5th Dec, 14:03 . Odds are subject to change.
Latest TV Articles
x
£20 Risk Free First bet on Strictly
New customers only, limited to one per person. If you’ve previously had a Paddy Power account, you will not qualify for the offer. Place your FIRST bet on any Sportsbook market and if it loses we will refund your stake in CASH. Max refund for this offer is  £20. Only deposits made using Cards or Paypal will qualify for this promotion. T&Cs apply. Paddy's Rewards Club: Get a  £10 free bet when you place 5x bets of  £10+. T&Cs apply.
BET HERE
We use cookies to provide statistics that help give you the best experience of our site. By continuing to use the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more
Got It
CLICK TO SEE THE LATEST TV SPECIALS ODDS ON REALITY BITE
18+ T&C’s APPLY Gamble Aware
CLICK TO SEE THE LATEST TV SPECIALS ODDS